提案讨论贴发布流程规范和模版指导

提案讨论阶段流程

不依照命名格式和发布规范的提案,可能将被论坛管理员认为是不合格提案,而不予置顶讨论。

1. 讨论大厅阶段

如果提案人希望在论坛上就提案内容征集意见,在讨论大厅发布提案讨论帖子,命名规范如下:

【提案讨论】+讨论主题+选择【讨论阶段】标签(确保为第一顺位标签)

讨论阶段请在根据讨论阶段,以下几种选项中选择标签:

  1. 意见征集(寻求社区意见,并起到预公示作用)
  2. 讨论关闭(意见征求结束,开始设计正式提案)
  3. 讨论取消(提案人放弃该提案设计)

提示,请根据讨论阶段修改帖子的对应标签,管理员也可能参与修改。

2. 提案讨论阶段

如果在讨论大厅已经经过充分的讨论,征集意见后,可以进入提案阶段了,提案人请在讨论大厅板块将相关讨论标签设置为【讨论关闭】,并在论坛的“提案讨论”板块编写并发布正式提案,开始进入提案投票前的正式公示和支持征集阶段。

如果提案人认为自己的提案已经完整,也可以跳过讨论大厅阶段,直接在“提案讨论” 板块发布提案。

:warning:一旦提案发布在“提案讨论”版块,并进入支持征集阶段后,提案正文内容不允许有内容性的修改,但可以在不改变提案内容的前提下,修改措辞,或者订正错别字。 :warning:

提案命名请遵守以下规范:

【提案编号】+提案名称+选择【提案阶段】标签(确保为第一顺位标签)

【提案编号】的格式为 WIP1 (具体数字请根据当时顺序填写)

提案阶段标签可以在以下选项中选择

  1. 支持征集
  2. 征集完毕
  3. 已通过
  4. 未通过

提案名称请尽可能简洁,建议可以根据解决什么问题,设计什么模式,开发什么产品为命名方式。

提示,请根据讨论阶段修改帖子的对应标签,管理员也可能参与修改。

如何发起投票,征集支持
在创建主题里如图点击创建投票


如有多种投票征集,在调查选项里增加

推荐的提案模版:

1) 前言

提案编号 / WIP:
提案名称:
提案作者:
有关提案: 和本提案有关的提案(如果有的话)
替换提案: 所要提换的以前提案(如果有的话)

2) 摘要

在此处用最简明扼要的语言介绍提案

3) 动机

用最直白的语言介绍为什么要提出该提案

4) 提案方案正文

提案正文建议有逻辑的讲清楚提案的具体方案,可以包括如下内容

  • 方案内容及执行步骤
  • 方案是否有时间表
  • 方案执行后可能带来的好处
  • 需要注意的方案的潜在风险
  • 是否有其他项目采用了类似的方案
  • 实施该方案可能需要哪些资源和协助
  • 建议由谁/团队来负责推进该方案

Proposal stage process

Proposals that do not follow the format specification may not be pinned on top for discussion.

1. General Chat stage

If the proponent wants to collect opinions on the content of the proposal on the forum, post a proposal discussion topic in the general chat category, and the specifications are as follows:

[Proposal discussion] + discussion topic + select [discussion] tags (make sure it is the first tag)

Please choose a tag from the following options according to the discussion stage:

  1. Opinions collection (seeking community opinions)
  2. Discussion closed (opinions collected successfull)
  3. Discussion cancelled (the draft proposal has been abandonedn)

Note: please modify the corresponding tag of the topic according to the discussion stage, administrators may also modify it.

2. Proposal Discussion stage

After full discussion and collection of opinions in the general chat category, it is proposal stage. Please modify the tag of the discussion topic to [Discussion closed] in the general chat category, and post the proposal in the Proposal Discussion category for the publicity and supports collection before the formal proposal voting.

If you think proposal does not need to be discussed, you can also skip the General Chat stage and publish the proposal directly in the Proposal Discussion category.

:warning: Once the proposal is posted in the Proposal Discussion category and enter the supports collection stage, you can revise statement and correct typos without changing the content of the proposal. The content of the proposal is not allowed to be modified with content, :warning:

Please follow the following specifications when posting a proposal:

[Proposal Number]+Proposal Name+Select the [Proposal Stage] tag (make sure it is the first tag)

The format of [Proposal Number] is WIP1 (Fill in the specific numbers according to the real-time order)

Proposal stage tag choose from the following options

  1. Support collection
  2. Collection completed
  3. Passed
  4. Failed

Keep the proposal name as concise as possible. Naming recommendation: what problem to solve, what model to design and what product to develop.

Note: please modify the tag of the topic according to proposal stage, administrators may also modify it.

How to create a vote in the topic
Click build in the topic as shown


If you need multiple options to vote, enter one option per line below

Recommended proposal template:

1) Preamble

Proposal number / WIP:
Proposal Title:
Proposal Author(s):
Related Proposals / Dependencies: Proposals related to this proposal (optional))
Replacement proposal / Replaces: The previous proposal to be replaced (optional))

2) Abstract

Concise proposal introduction

3) Motivation

Concisely explain why the proposal was made

4) Specification/Proposal Details

A specific proposal with clear logic and express fluently, can including the following

  • Proposal content and execution steps
  • Proposal schedule
  • Benefits after execution
  • Potential risks of proposal that need attention
  • Any other projects with similar strategy
  • Resources and assistance that may be required for execution
  • Suggest person/team for the proposal execution